iPhone OS 3.0 breaking video out

Filed under: Hardware , Multimedia , iPhone , iPod touch iPhone OS 3.0 Video break out

Dave Caolo ( RSS feed ) At 31 August 2009 at 4:00 PM / Yesterday evening I received an email from a friend who w? had tend. He has with its iPod touch as a mobile video-L? Sung with a dock-and video-out cable. The iPod and the cable has been pr? Chtig until he upgraded to iPhone OS 3.0.1 OS 3.0 [sorry, there is no 3.0.1 f? R iPod touch]. Now refuses to recognize the iPod. Same cable, a dock, same iPod. We looked around and found there? He is not alone. There are a thread on Apple's Discussion Boards reporting? About the same thing. It is both the iPod touch and iPhone. Apparently 3.0 is specifically for 3rd party cable refuse to comply strictly with the Pr? Premise that they are “out of Apple's Made” test. A poster on the discussion board notes that the original Apple Component AV Cable and dock work fine. Nat? Rlich k? Again and seems to produce nnten demotion, but that's being silly. Nat? rlich no company has a responsibility to 3rd-Party-Ger? te at the bottom tzen? so my friend out of luck. But we are sympathetic. If you are affected by this problem, then everything we say k? Can, it probably is time to f? R a pony cable from Apple. Tweet this Comments ( 24 ) / * Some crap that is * / function IECheck (inc_seven) ( / / alert (navigator.appName); ?? if (navigator.appName == “Win32″ & & navigator. appName == “Microsoft Internet Explorer” & & window.attachEvent) ( ???????? navigator.appVersion.match var rslt = (/ MSIE (\ d + \. \ d +) /, ' '); ???????? iever var =) inc_seven (? rslt (! = null & & Number (rslt [1])> = 5.5): (rslt = null & & Number (rslt [1])> = 5.5 & & Number (rslt [1]) '; normalBrand var =' '; var brand =''; if (useFilter == false) ( brand = normalBrand; ) Else ( brand = ie6Brand; )

Related articles from The Unofficial Apple Weblog in Las Vegas? Bring your own video to The Mirage

5 days ago iLounge releases videos of iPhone 3G speed test S

71 days ago grab your U.S. Army-issue iPod touch, soldier!

104 days ago Last night I received an email from a friend who was irate. He's been using his iPod touch as a portable video solution with a dock and video out cable. The iPod and the cable got along famously until he updated to iPhone OS 3.0.1 OS 3.0 [sorry, there isn't a 3.0.1 for the iPod touch]. Now, the iPod refuses to recognize it. Same cable, same dock, same iPod. We looked around and found that he's not alone. There's a thread on Apple's Discussion Boards reporting the same thing. It's affecting both the iPod touch and the iPhone. Apparently 3.0 is specifically designed to reject 3rd party cables, strictly on the premise that they fail the “Made by Apple” test. One poster on the discussion board notes that the original Apple Component AV cable and dock work fine. Sure, you could restore and downgrade, but that seems silly. Of course, no company has a responsibility to support 3rd party devices, so my friend is out of luck. But we're sympathetic. If you're affected by this issue, all we can say is it's probably time to pony up for a cable from Apple.

Tags: av cable, AvCable, dock, iphone, ipod touch, IpodTouch, video out, VideoOut

SourcePrint thisWith HP wireless printers, you could have printed this from any room in the house.Live wirelessly. Print wirelesslyEmail this addthis_pub = 'weblogsinc'; addthis_options = 'digg, facebook, delicious, myspace, aolfav, propeller, google, live, stumbleupon, reddit, favorites, technorati, aim, more'; Share Tweet this!Comments (24) /* some ie crap */ function iecheck(inc_seven) { // alert(navigator.platform); if (navigator.platform == “Win32″ && navigator.appName == “Microsoft Internet Explorer” && window.attachEvent) { var rslt = navigator.appVersion.match(/MSIE (\d+\.\d+)/, ''); var iever = (inc_seven)?(rslt != null && Number(rslt[1]) >= 5.5):(rslt != null && Number(rslt[1]) >= 5.5 && Number(rslt[1]) < 7 ); } else { iever=false; } return iever; } var useFilter=iecheck(false); var ie6Brand=''; var normalBrand=''; var brand=''; if(useFilter==false) { brand=normalBrand; } else { brand=ie6Brand; }

Related Articles From The Unofficial Apple WeblogIn Las Vegas? Bring your own video to The Mirage

5 days ago

iLounge releases speed test videos of iPhone 3G S

71 days ago

Grab your US Army-issue iPod touch, soldier!

104 days ago

Related Articles From Our Tech NetworkThe Daily Roundup: here's what you might've missed

4 days ago

Sirius XM readying SkyDock iPhone / iPod touch accessory and more?

10 days ago

Rotaliana Diva iPod / iPhone dock vamps up your situation

28 days ago

See More Related Articles and Blog Posts

document.getElementById('spherePoweredBy').innerHTML=brand; Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)

1Josh said 4:16PM on 8-31-2009

What I want to know is this… how did he get his iPod updated to 3.0.1? That was an iPhone only update. Something else must be wrong.

↓↑report2Dhave said 4:26PM on 8-31-2009

I agree, there is something fishy about this story.

↓↑report3TimH said 4:17PM on 8-31-2009

Companies may not have a responsibility to support 3rd party devices, but it's common courtesy, good customer service, and, well, just sensible, to not go out of your way to block them. Especially when the product is an A/V cable. I mean, c'mon. What did Apple do, hire a former Monster Cable exec who insists that a label on the outside somehow makes metal conduct electricity better?Seriously.

↓↑report4Grog said 4:23PM on 8-31-2009

Agreed with above: there's a distinct difference between supporting a 3rd party device and actively blocking it. Apple has every right to laugh if a 3rd party cable doesn't work or somehow manages to fry your iPod or monitor, but I disagree that they should be able to actually prevent the use of it.

↓↑report5SteveJr_Ri said 4:23PM on 8-31-2009

I was affected by this, and it sucks, frankly. Why do I have to buy a $30-40 cable when the $10 version does exactly what I need it to do? (until they blocked it of course)

↓↑report6Josh said 4:30PM on 8-31-2009

I was just going to say that… however, Apple does have some regulations about their products. The $10 cables aren't authorized by Apple, as that chip probably costs somewhere between 20-30 extra bucks. I don't think Apple is wrong in cutting off access through these cables, as it directly violates their iPod accessory rule, but I think that this is only going to hurt Apple- they have had too many “lock down” issues as of late- let this one go, I says.

↓↑report7SteveJr_Ri said 4:36PM on 8-31-2009

I can understand it may not have all the “features” as the Apple cable, and I'm not asking them to support it either. But what makes me mad is that the cable WORKS. If i plug it in and play video it works for all of 30seconds until the dreaded “This Accessory is not supported by this iPod”. Thats where I'm angry, not that it just won't work period. Stuff like this frustrates me and makes me think next time I go to buy a replacement for this type of device. Am I going to want something that I am going to have to dump serious $$ into or will I go with an alternative with not as many features. Unfortunately sometime the $$$ wins

↓↑report8wes said 4:28PM on 8-31-2009

Its just like Apple to pull a dick move like that.

↓↑report9Garrett said 4:37PM on 8-31-2009

I have a Pure-Fi Anywhere 2 from Logitech. My iPhone 3G used to place nice with it and the remote control could change songs etc. Now when I dock my phone it states “this device was not made for the iPhone” and the remote does not work.It worked before but not since the 3.0 upgrade. Maybe it is related.

↓↑report10HazyCloud said 4:39PM on 8-31-2009

I recently bought a “I3G” power cable for 8 clams. To this day with 3.0.1, my iPhone still charges with it. I'd honestly be a little pissed to update my firmware only to realize something I bought now doesn't work.

↓↑report11bjhanifin said 4:49PM on 8-31-2009

Sounds very monopolistic to me!!! Apparently apple isn't making enough money, and needs to extort more money out of their customers. P.S. I have a MacBook Pro and am a fan of Apple quality, but I don't like hearing of anti-competitive behavior like this.

↓↑report12Joey said 5:39PM on 8-31-2009

I agree. I'm an early iPhone adopter and avid consumer of all things Mac and although I love my iPhone and still insist that it's the best smartphone I've ever owned, I'm becoming less and less enamored with the iPhone OS and Apple in general.So much so that I recently purchased a Nokia N800 Internet tablet running Maemo 2008 as in impulse buy ($99 refurb on Ebay!) just to see how the rest of the mobile space is evolving. It's got full multi-tasking, no ridiculous app regulations (it's all open source), two SD cards slots, USB host adapter that works with a standard USB keyboard, terminal, full FTP, Bluetooth tethering, bit torrent, Skype and a sexy OS… just wow.If only Apple were even as remotely open about things I think we'd be seeing a lot more advancement within the platform.

↓↑report13EF said 5:09PM on 8-31-2009

If your iPhone/iPod touch is jailbroken, here is the fix:Original post (seems dead now, but there is Google cache!)http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=”DealExtreme+Product+Forum:+Solution+for+OS+3.0+!!!!!”&aq=f&oq=&aqi=——————————Ok I've found a solution for this cable to work with OS 3.0, but you need a jailbroken iPhone 3G (more info about jailbreak: http://blog.iphone-dev.org/ ). So what you need to do: 1. download file: http://www.2shared.com/file/6511223/3592322d/iapd.html 2. ssh to your device and browse to: /System/Library/PrivateFrameworks/IAP.framework/Support 3. replace existing iapd in this folder with downloaded-one 4. set file attributes (CHMOD) to 755 5. reboot the device NOW TRY AND BE HAPPY CUZ IT WORKS!——————————It works for my iPod touch OS 3.0 with the freaking cheap iPod Composite AV Cable playing photos on the TV screen!

↓↑report14EF said 5:11PM on 8-31-2009

Google Cache:http://74.125.95.132/search?q=cache:nOPk-NhnexwJ:www2.dealextreme.com/forums/Forums.dx/Forum.20278~threadid.372039+%22DealExtreme+Product+Forum:+Solution+for+OS+3.0+!!!!!%22&cd=1&hl=zh-TW&ct=clnk&gl=usOriginal Post:http://www2.dealextreme.com/forums/Forums.dx/Forum.20278~threadid.372039

↓↑report15Sam said 5:12PM on 8-31-2009

This is wrong. Microsoft wouldn't be allowed to get away with it nor should apple. The fact that you have conceded the fight without ever taking it is also wrong.

↓↑report16Chris said 5:19PM on 8-31-2009

I had the same problem with 3.0. I've got a 3GS so I've never seen it work but when I went to plug my phone into my car port it would play music but not charge, it also said the same thing everybody else is saying. I bought a small adapter from sports chalet for $20 and it works fine now. I think the company is schosche or something like that. Seems to work with all the unauthorized cables as well.

↓↑report17Josue R Sencion said 5:22PM on 8-31-2009

Have you ever heard about “externalized costs”? this is the very same thing SJ is trying to stop, i think. Shure they can sell a 500 dollars computer, shure they can sell a 10 dollars accesory, but at the end all they want to do is to compensate right every part of the line, from the conception of the product to the final consumer. It all makes sense, look at the Apple Store! you always see happy people working there. Heck! sometimes i see myself working as a geniuos guy. What kind of company spends money so you can extend your battery life a couple of more years??? none! because that means less more distant sales, isn't it? well, apple does it, and does it very well. I dont know, maybe at the end iam only an apple blinded fan or maybe iam right, either one iam pleased a company like Apple is doing this well so far…

↓↑report18Josue R Sencion said 5:26PM on 8-31-2009

I forgot to put a link for those who dosen't know what “externalized costs” means: http://www.storyofstuff.com/

↓↑report19eugene said 5:26PM on 8-31-2009

I had a similar issue with my 1G iTouch and the mini-speaker I bought for it online. It still worked, but kept interrupting games/videos with the “accessory not supported” window. I solved it by instlling “Popup Blocker” from Cydia. It costs 99 cents and does the job. The only problem that remains is that when the speaker is attached, the iPod never falls asleep and keeps draining the battery.

↓↑report20drossie said 5:28PM on 8-31-2009

My in case 2 in 1 charger no longer works with 3.0paid $40 bucks for it!

↓↑report var req; function getURL(url) { if(isWorking == true) { setTimeout(“getURL(\”"+url+”\”)”, “100″); return false; } isWorking = true; if (window.XMLHttpRequest) { req = new XMLHttpRequest(); req.onreadystatechange = handleHttpResponse; req.open(“GET”, url, true); req.send(null); } else if (window.ActiveXObject) { // IE try { req = new ActiveXObject(“Msxml2.XMLHTTP”); } catch (e) { req = new ActiveXObject(“Microsoft.XMLHTTP”); } if (req) { req.onreadystatechange = handleHttpResponse; req.open(“GET”, url, true); req.send(); } else { alert(“Your browser does not support ajax”); } } else { alert(“Your browser does not support ajax”); } return false; } function postURL(url,outbuf) { if(isWorking == true) { setTimeout(“postURL(\”"+url+”\”,\”"+outbuf+”\”)”, “100″); return false; } isWorking = true; var browser = navigator.appName; if(browser != “Microsoft Internet Explorer”) { req = new XMLHttpRequest(); req.onreadystatechange = handleHttpResponse; req.open(“POST”, url, true); req.setRequestHeader(“Content-Type”,”application/x-www-form-urlencoded; charset=UTF-8″); req.send(outbuf); } else if (window.ActiveXObject) { // IE req = new ActiveXObject(“Microsoft.XMLHTTP”); if (req) { req.onreadystatechange = handleHttpResponse; req.open(“POST”, url, true); req.setRequestHeader(“Content-Type”,”application/x-www-form-urlencoded; charset=UTF-8″); req.send(outbuf); } } return false; } function handleHttpResponse() { if (req.readyState == 4) { if(req.responseText.charAt(0) == “Last night I received an email from a friend who was irate. He's been using his iPod touch as a portable video solution with a dock and video out cable. The iPod and the cable got along famously until he updated to iPhone OS 3.0.1 OS 3.0 [sorry, there isn't a 3.0.1 for the iPod touch]. Now, the iPod refuses to recognize it. Same cable, same dock, same iPod. We looked around and found that he's not alone. There's a thread on Apple's Discussion Boards reporting the same thing. It's affecting both the iPod touch and the iPhone. Apparently 3.0 is specifically designed to reject 3rd party cables, strictly on the premise that they fail the “Made by Apple” test. One poster on the discussion board notes that the original Apple Component AV cable and dock work fine. Sure, you could restore and downgrade, but that seems silly. Of course, no company has a responsibility to support 3rd party devices, so my friend is out of luck. But we're sympathetic. If you're affected by this issue, all we can say is it's probably time to pony up for a cable from Apple.